“Gravel”-Style Rubs: How to Easily Copy-cat their Recipes

Last Updated:
May 30, 2024

Save yourself money and start making these rubs YOURSELF.

All these rubs really boil down to are:

  1. Larger granule sizes for salt and pepper.
  2. Dehydrated versions of spices like onion, garlic, and more.

After that, it’s just a matter of finding the stuff YOU like to add.

Just want the recipe?
Click here to jump to it!

The Pepper

For this ingredient use I use two types of Pepper. Use 1 tablespoon of 16 Mesh (Butcher Block) Black Pepper and 1 tablespoon of 30 Mesh (Medium Grind) black pepper.

The key here is to buy black pepper that’s already pre-cracked.

30 mesh and 16 mesh black pepper side by side for rub

The reason for not using freshly ground black pepper is because it’s too pungent. Where-as pre-cracked pepper has allowed some of the terpenes and alkaloids to evaporate – making it less spicy.

Typically the Pepper that’s used here is between 16 and 30 mesh – I like to use both.

The Salt

For this ingredient use 1 tablespoon of Morton’s Kosher Salt.

The key here is to use kosher salt – either Morton’s or Diamond Crystal work great – or any generic brand of Kosher salt.

Personally, I use Morton’s because it’s cheap.

diamond crystal kosher salt and mortons kosher salt side by side for rub
Diamond Crystal Left, Morton’s Right

Diamond Crystal does tend to mix better than Morton’s but if you simply shake the bottle regularly, you’ll combat the dissociation of the salt.

Keep in Mind: Morton’s and Diamond Crystal have different densities. If you only have Diamond crystal, use double the amount I recommend here (2 tablespoons).

Also, don’t substitute regular table salt – it’s a fine granule and won’t remotely taste the same.

Dehydrated Onion and Dehydrated Garlic

Use 1/2 tablespoon of both Dehydrated Minced Onion and Dehydrated Minced Garlic.

These ingredients provide umami taste sensations and the dehydrated, Minced version mixes far better than the Granulated or Powdered versions in a gravel-style rub.

dehydrated minced onion and garlic for rub
Minced Onion Left, Minced Garlic Right

Other Ingredients?

Technically after the above you’ve covered most “gravel” type rubs, but from here you can start to have fun and add ingredients and modify the rub to your liking.

For instance, Cuso’s Gravel rub uses:

Another is Malcolm Reed’s Steak Rub:

Right Way BBQ’s Steak Rub:

  • Garlic
  • Dehydrated Onion

Montreal Steak Seasoning:

  • Red pepper flakes
  • Coriander Seed
  • Mustard seed
  • Dill

You get the gist.

These are very simple rubs that will typically run you between $10-15 (not including shipping) and can be made MUCH MUCH cheaper at home.

Personally, the only other thing I typically add is 1/2 tablespoon of:

I’ll typically grind this in a coffee grinder for 3-ish presses.

Is Buying the Ingredients Actually Cheaper than Buying a Pre-made Rub

Yes.

We’ll break this down by volume with popular commercially available options you’ll see on Social Media:

Cuso’s Gravel5 oz. bottle / $11.99 = $2.39/oz.
Malcolm Reed’s Steak Rub11 oz. bottle / $9.97 (on sale) = $0.9/oz.
Right Way BBQ Steak Rub10.2 oz. bottle / $9.99 (on sale) = $0.98/oz.

Cost Per Ingredient*

*Most of the specialty ingredients I buy from Spices Inc. but some I buy from the Grocery store, Amazon, or Walmart.

Badia Butcher Block Black Pepper$16.99 / 16 oz. = $1.06/oz.
Morton Kosher Salt$2.12 / 16 oz. = $0.13/oz.
Badia Dehydrated Minced Onion$3.17 / 5.5 oz. = $0.58/oz.
Spices Inc. Medium Grind Black Pepper$15.75 / 16 oz. = $0.98/oz.
Happy Belly Dehydrated Minced Onion$6.86 / 15 oz. = $0.46/oz

Made at home, with my measurements:

Badia Butcher Block Black Pepper1 tbsp or 0.23 oz. = $0.24
Morton Kosher Salt1 tbsp or 0.61 oz. = $0.08
Badia Dehydrated Minced Onion1/2 tbsp or 0.14 oz. = $0.08
Spices Inc. Medium Grind Black Pepper1 tbsp or 0.25 oz. = $0.25
Happy Belly Dehydrated Minced Onion1/2 tbsp or 0.17 oz. =$0.08

My Cost Totals:

Total Weight = 1.4 oz.

Total Cost = $0.73

  • Dylan’s Gravel Rub = $0.52/oz
  • Cuso’s Rub = $2.39/oz.
  • Malcolm’s Rub= $0.9/oz.
  • Right Way BBQ;s Rub = $0.98/oz.

Again, none of the commercial options have shipping factored in either, which would only increase the cost per oz.

Though most of Malcolm’s rubs are found in most Walmarts.

Needless to say though, I will never buy one of these rubs and I’d rather just make it at home and buy the singular spice difference and add it to my base outlined above and below.

Granted, the upfront cost is more simply due to the fact that you have to buy these ingredients in bulk. But you’ll use them all over time regardless.

Copycat “Gravel” BBQ Rubs

Wicked simple and Made MUCH Cheaper at Home
Prep Time5 minutes
Total Time5 minutes
Course: Rubs

Ingredients

  • 1/2 tbsp Dehydrated Minced Onion
  • 1/2 tbsp Dehydrated Minced Garlic
  • 1 tbsp Morton Kosher Salt
  • 1 tbsp Medium Grind Black Pepper
  • 1 tbsp 16 Mesh Black Pepper

Instructions

  • In a bowl combine the above ingredients in the specified quantities.
dylan bio profile picture
Dylan Clay
Dylan Clay is a pitmaster based in New Hampshire, with over 17 years of experience in grilling, smoking, and dehydrating meat. Throughout this time, he has worked with nearly every cut of meat. In 2019, he launched the Barbecue FAQ website to share his extensive knowledge about all things meat, aiming to assist others in making better barbecue at home.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this Recipe




magnifiercrossmenu linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram